Taste Tests

The Marmalade Report

A running record from the Belleville Standards Bureau, Marmalade Division.

All reviews are unpaid. I bought my own stuff because nobody paid me to say these mostly unkind things. Some links may be Amazon affiliate links, which means I might earn literal pennies if you buy through them. Better yet, click one of my affiliate links and then immediately go buy an above-ground pool so I can earn THAT commission.

Tasting notesVideo review
SmuckersSweet Orange MarmaladeJelly is very sweet, not very orangey, a lot of chunks4https://www.instagram.com/p/DZyHIahNoWk/
Bonne MamanOrange MarmaladeGood colour, less pulp, terribly bitter and unpleasant (like medicine); vile1https://www.instagram.com/p/DZyHIahNoWk/
ChiversOlde English MarmaladeVery dark brown colour, tastes like a condiment you’d put with pork (like chutney), almost savoury4.5https://www.instagram.com/p/DZyHIahNoWk/
PolanerSweet OrangeClear jelly, tastes like orange, sweet with much skinnier bits of pulp7.5https://www.instagram.com/p/DZ3W9NFNgDO/
MacKayThree Fruit Marmalade (Orange, Grapefruit & Lemon)Clear jelly, solid texture, less sweet, more grapefruit forward, chunky8https://www.instagram.com/p/DZ3W9NFNgDO/
Whole Foods Market 365Organic Orange Marmalade Fruit SpreadPureed texture, very bright orange flavour. Not clear, good introduction if you’ve never had marmalade before7.5https://www.instagram.com/p/DZ3W9NFNgDO/
Stonewall KitchenBlood Orange MarmaladeCloudy, more jammy, a lot of pulp, tastes like orange, not sour7.5https://www.instagram.com/p/DaWOCcaA0aZ/
TrappistSweet Orange MarmaladeRunny texture, a lot of pulp, jelly is sweet (similar to Polaner), I’d like something more bitter than this7https://www.instagram.com/p/DaWOCcaA0aZ/
RobertsonsGolden ShredLooks like apple jelly with only a few pieces of pulp, strong, sour, and is unusual but not in a good way, really too weird, acidic (nearly alcoholic), no forward flavour of orange6https://www.instagram.com/p/DaWOCcaA0aZ/
AgrisiciliaSicilian Lemon MarmaladeTexture is like a canned pear, tastes like Pledge and airport disinfectant6https://www.instagram.com/p/Dad77VyNoyW/
BonoSicilian Blood OrangeSmells like tomato, pureed texture like ground beef, how can this be top of the line? Very sour, terrible mouthfeel3https://www.instagram.com/p/Dad77VyNoyW/
Campo D’oroBlood Orange JamThe best flavour so, far, but the texture is completely wrong. Pureed mush, runny. Contains a fractional bit of salt which really seems to help.6.5https://www.instagram.com/p/Dad77VyNoyW/
Marks & SpencerSeville Orange (fine cut)Quite good, looser texture. Sour, but orange-y.7https://www.instagram.com/p/Dalr5PWNVIj/
WaitroseSeville Orange Marmalade (thick cut)Firm texture, darker colour, orange, bitter, texture is good (sour but not crazy, good balance)7.5https://www.instagram.com/p/Dalr5PWNVIj/
TescoTangy Bitter Orange Marmalade (medium cut)Very firm, peel is bitter, jelly part is not too sweet, I like this one, too7.5https://www.instagram.com/p/Dalr5PWNVIj/
FruitfieldOld Time Irish (Coarse Cut) Orange MarmaladeBeyond chunky, bordering on woodchips, ‘disagreeable’4https://www.instagram.com/p/DatQ9WFNQWJ/
FruitfieldOld Time Irish (Fine Cut) Orange MarmaladeNot bright enough (tastes like citrus jam with lint)5.5https://www.instagram.com/p/DatQ9WFNQWJ/
MileevenIrish Breakfast MarmaladeVery sour, not orangey, tastes ‘depressing’4https://www.instagram.com/p/DatQ9WFNQWJ/
SarabethOrange Apricot MarmaladeGood loose consistency, some VERY large pieces of peel though. Has a honey-flavour background.7https://www.instagram.com/p/Da1KeSiNTdf/
Tiptree‘Old Times’ OrangeVery firm, thin pieces of peel that are quite long. So very sour. Good orange flavour, though super bitter. Thought this was going to be the winner (!)6.75https://www.instagram.com/p/Da1KeSiNTdf/
MackaysDundee OrangeFirm, orangey, lots of texture but not hairy. Actually tastes like orange (phew!)8https://www.instagram.com/p/Da1KeSiNTdf/
TiptreeOrange & TangerineLooser texture, smaller pieces, bright orange flavour, rounder notes. Liking this one ;)8https://www.instagram.com/reel/Da3qKs8tXfj/
RobertsonsSeville Orange MarmaladeDespite the aroma of shoe polish and the texture of carpet, it has a good bright orange flavour, a deep aroma, and a kind of ‘honey’ like backtaste. I didn’t hate it :)7.25https://www.instagram.com/reel/Da8y93iNr2I/
Marmalade GrovePixie TangerineSweet, looser texture, good flavour, could perhaps be a bit more bitter, but i’m splitting hairs (!).8https://www.instagram.com/p/Da_YX4utLOO/
JayoneHoney Yuzu TeaLoose, bright flavour, not too sour, surprisingly good8https://www.instagram.com/p/DbHDVS2gZAV/
SurasangHoney Citron TeaLoose texture, a good sweet honey flavour and good amount of bitter pith for balance. much better than lots of others that i’ve tried8.5https://www.instagram.com/p/DbHDVS2gZAV/
Marmalade GroveMeyer Lemon & HoneyVery thin pieces, sour but not bitter, honey flavour, a little runny. Not bad.7https://www.instagram.com/reel/DbOkbzot3Cp/
TiptreeLemonAll the pith is at the top, needs a big stir. Tastes like Maynards Wine Gums. Nicer than I thought it would be. Looser texture.8https://www.instagram.com/reel/DbOkbzot3Cp/